Let's Talk

20 years of
Living Theology in the Metropolitan Chicago Synod since 1996

  • Home
  • Issues
    • Welcome to Let’s Talk 2020
    • 22. 2 Reformation Jubilee 500
    • 22.1 Death and Dying
    • All Issues 1996 – present
  • Noted Guest Authors
  • About
  • Contact

Powered by Genesis

You are here: Home / Ministerial Formation / Letters to the Editor

Letters to the Editor

May 25, 2016 by Editorial Council

I meant to drop you a note after the Easter, 1996 issue of Let’s Talk. It’s when the Advent 1996 edition arrived that I realized I have been negligent.

I am referring specifically to the Leon Rosenthal article, “The Foundation: Finding Unity as Biblical People of Promise.” Considering the wretched history of Christian-Jewish relationships, our persistent and consistent anti-Semitism, and Luther’s unforgivable diatribe [Von den Juden und ihre Luegen], I take issue with Rosenthal’s affirmation that “A first requirement of dialogue is humility.” I believe with all my heart that our “first requirement” must be confession of sin and public repentance for 2,000 years of wrongdoing against our Jewish sisters and brothers.

Rosenthal even says that the ELCA statement concerning Luther’s anti-Semitic publication has never received wide distribution. Why not? Isn’t it important? Or is it just more anti-Semitism?

Back in the 1980s I did my D.Min. entirely on the theology of Baptism. My narrow (sacramental theology) focus was permitted at that time for D.Min. applicants, which I deeply appreciated.

But one of my discoveries was that, as Lutherans (not to mention other Christian persuasions) we have never spoken a word of repentance nor a request for forgiveness from our believer-baptist or Anabaptist neighbors (or their descendants) for our horrendous maltreatment of them during and after Reformation times–treatment that included murder “in the name of Christ!” The believer-baptism people have taken note of our failure to confess our wrongs, but we have never replied to them officially or specifically.

Confession and forgiveness is a foundational stance in the Christian life for us as individuals. Why not for us as church bodies? It certainly would appear to be the place to begin our dialogues.

Gerald L. Rygh
Vice Pastor, Our Savior, Aurora


I picked up a copy of the Easter 1996 Let’s Talk at the synod assembly and have enjoyed reading the articles in it. As a member of the MCS Lutheran-Jewish Dialogue I am very interested in issues dealing with ecumenism and dialogue.

Nancy Oakford
Rolling Meadows


We will print more from our congregation mission statement contest in a future issue.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Filed Under: Ministerial Formation


Let’s Talk welcomes thoughtful responses to our articles from all readers. Post your thoughts on our Facebook page or scroll down to the bottom to leave a comment.

Subscriber Sign-up

2.1 Epiphany 1997

2.1 Epiphany 1997

In This Issue

What They Did Teach Me at Seminary: Thoughts of a First Call Pastor

By Robin Curie

Servants Ready to Listen

By Philip Hefner

A Response to Philip Hefner

By Frank C. Senn

Getting Support through Mutual Ministry and Continuing Education

By Anne Lee

Mentoring and Pastoral Formation

By F. Dean Lueking

“Maceration of the Minister” Revisited

By John Seraphine

First Call Theological Education

By Constance Leean Seraphine

Taking Time for the Soul

By Jack Finney

To Be “God With Skin On”

By Judith Rae Swanson

Letters to the Editor

By Editorial Council